Tuesday, August 12, 2025

The Lord of the Rings: The Siege of Gondor (Part 9)


The Tale

The City is now besieged, ringed with foes. The sheltering Rammas wall is broken and all the Pelennor fields abandoned and left to the enemy. Men come running along the northward road before the Gate is finally shut. They are led by Ingold, who let Gandalf and Pippin in only five days ago, ‘while the sun still rose and there was hope in the morning.’

He brings no news of the Rohirrim; even if they do come, it won’t help, he thinks. The host coming their way is very strong. Battalions of Orcs of the Eye, and companies of a sort of men they’ve never seen before. Broad, bearded like dwarves, and wielding great axes. The northward road (from which Rohan is most likely to come) is held by these forces. ‘The Rohirrim cannot come.’

The Gate is shut against the siege. All night the enemy burn field and tree, and kill any man they find, chopping up even the dead. They can’t tell how many of them have passed over the river, but come morning, such as it is, the plain is dark with their marching companies and great camps of black and red tents have sprouted up ‘like a foul fungus.’

And Sauron’s forces are digging great trenches, behind which they set up great engines to cast missiles. There are no such devices on the walls of Minas Tirith strong enough to throw anything far enough to stop their construction. But the defenders of the City are not overly concerned. The walls are high, and ‘built ere the power and craft of Numenor waned in exile, and its outward face was like to the Tower of Orthanc, hard and dark and smooth.’

But the engines are not there to break the wall, but to sow confusion and fear among the defenders. Some volleys are aimed over the wall and burst into flame, bringing peril and drawing away forces from defending the walls. There is a lesser cast from the great catapults, but more terrible, bringing great woe. ‘For the enemy was flinging into the City all the heads of those who had fallen fighting’, faces contorted in pain when they can be recognized and not merely crushed and shapeless, but all branded with the Lidless Eye. Some see people they knew when alive.

The pitiless foe heed not the Gondor men’s curses, clamoring in ‘harsh voices like beast or carrion-birds.’ But worse than that are the calls of the flying Nazgul, circling like vultures, who ride above beyond sight or bowshot, filling all who hear them with dread and despair, freezing their will. And the effect just gets worse with every scream; there is no getting used to it.

‘At length even the stout-hearted would fling themselves to the ground as the hidden menace passed over them, or they would stand, letting their weapons fall from nerveless hands while into their minds a blackness came, and they thought no more of war, but only of hiding and of crawling, and of death.’

Notes

The exact name of this group of previously unknown men fighting for Sauron is not clear; perhaps they are the ‘Easterlings with axes’ mentioned later. Their description makes them sound very Dwarf-like, and there has been some speculation (unfounded from anything Tolkien wrote) that they were ‘half-dwarves’ or at least taught or influenced by Dwarves some time in their history. Perhaps it was only ‘parallel evolution’.

I remember describing the ‘head-flinging’ incident to my Uncle Bazzell, trying to match his gruesome details from Scottish border history.

The efforts of the Witch King were not the tactics of ‘some brigand or Orc-chieftain’ but calculated psychological warfare to soften his enemies up and impress upon them the futility of their position. The effect of the Nazgul cries were more effective than any swooping down on siege engines or casting soldiers from the walls, as featured in the Jackson movies.

I’m slowly grinding my way through the chapter, laying siege, as it were, to The Siege of Gondor, hoping to finally conquer it by slow attrition.

No comments:

Post a Comment